Most P65 warning labels usually all have the same last sentence: “For more information go to www.p65warnings.ca.gov.” If you live in California, cancer warnings seem to be lurking around every corner — on grocery store shelves, at the gas pump or even in the window of your … That said, this is a low-grade tea. It was just easier to put a warning on the product than deal with nuisance lawsuits. “ WARNING: This product can expose you to chemicals including arsenic, which is known to the State of California to cause cancer. Any moms know anything about the prop 65 warning I know I have seen it on literally so many random things from things like sunglasses to furniture and wondering if any one was worried? The legislation was passed to protect consumers from potentially hazardous chemicals, and enforcement of it would come from customers expecting the products they buy to not have scary looking labels on them. There is a downside to being inundated with cancer warnings, Reeves says. what is the name of that chemical? There are a lot of nuisance lawsuits. I once ordered artist grade Schmincke watercolours and it came with a label like that! I'm not sure if this is helpful, but here's the list of chemicals that make the Prop 65 list. ; Some household appliances may expose you to chemicals on the Proposition 65 list such as benzene, carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, and some flame retardants and phthalates. Worry is pointless, and you are not eating food directly off of it nor using it to do brain surgery out of. Quality is very important to me. I wouldn’t worry. Edit: was just in CA last week, and saw Prop 65 warnings in Starbucks about a chemical that occurs naturally when baking sweets. Like, ridiculously broad. The manual gives the California proposition 65 warning "WARNING: This product contains chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. Many manufacturers place such labels on their products because they don't want the hassle. There are other U.S. States which drafted their own equivalents to Prop.65 which basically duplicated the testing and standards. But you are coming into contact with it. In August 2016, OEHHA adopted new regulations, effective on August 30, 2018, which change the information required in Proposition 65 warnings. Proposition 65 — the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 — requires businesses to provide warnings to Californians about significant exposures to chemicals that cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm. I have the same tin and drink the tea. Compliance will also be time consuming as customers come looking for Prop 65 information. A Prop 65 warning does not automatically mean that the product is unsafe. The warning labels can be found on many kinds of products, such as electrical wires, jewelry, padlocks, dishes, flashlights, and pesticides, to name just a few. That label is on a bunch of products. This subreddit is for discussion of beverages made from soaking camellia sinensis leaves (or twigs) in water, and, to a lesser extent, herbal infusions, yerba mate, and other tisanes. Which makes it pointless. Prop 65 includes a list of more than 900 chemicals “ that have been shown to potentially cause cancer or birth defects,” Fisher says. However, the testing required under Proposition 65 is very extensive, and expensive. Even tomatoes contain "chemicals known... to cause cancer". Frequent, non-specific signage has led some consumers to tune warnings out, thus decreasing their risk awareness. Its just easier to label it on every product you make regardless of where it may be sold. The California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment is establishing this website to provide the public with information on chemicals, products and locations often associated with Proposition 65 warnings. I suggest not drinking it. New Prop 65 Requirements. If the Prop 65 warnings are everywhere, then perhaps that opinion is merited by some. So not every Prop 65 warning should be equally alarming. The law only exist in California, so if I want to sell the product in California, I have to label it on all products sold in California. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the explainlikeimfive community. If you don’t live in California, do you need to worry about P65 warnings? The answer to this question is ultimately up to you. Reeves believes that Proposition 65’s new rules may make cancer warnings more specific and beneficial. From hand gloves to chair cushions and spray cans to hardware tools, a variety of common household products are labeled with warnings stating that item may have substances known to the State of California to cause cancer or reproductive harm. Could be the in the container, so I'd say wash your hands after handling, but I'm inclined to believe it's really referencing the tea itself. Originally Prop 65 required companies to put a warning on their product’s label if there was one or more of the listed chemicals in the product. I haven’t missed it since I upgraded. California passed a law that said products sold in that state that are made with chemicals linked to cancer have to have a warning on them, so consumers know that using that product can increase your cancer risk. The warnings are the result of the California Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986. In 2013, Gov. Some think the Prop 65 labels have desensitized the public, or have caused undue hype. The bad tea just materializes into wholesaler warehouses. It would look like one or both of these: WARNING: This product contains a chemical known to … Nah, the thresholds set on Prop 65 are so low it essentially make it meaningless. Why do products or foods have P65 warnings? We also cannot answer questions regarding how long and at what level the chemical exposures have been occurring. 65 warnings. Welcome to the Proposition 65 Warnings Website. If you don’t live in California, do you need to worry about P65 warnings? For many companies, even large ones, actually going through the process of certifying that their products contain no potentially hazardous chemicals (according to Prop.65) is not worth it. It's everywhere and you kind of get desensitized to it. It actually became an industrial standard to just not bother at all, and put the disclaimer on the side. This law has resulted in safer products and practices. It only causes cancer there. I would think critically about each instance. I wonder... considering the volume of things on the list https://oehha.ca.gov/media/downloads/proposition-65/p65111017_0.pdf it is entirely possible they did what a lot of other companies do and just blanket put it on anything going to california. If I don’t live in California, do I need to worry about P65 warnings? California passed Proposition 65 a few decades ago, which requires the state to maintain a list of chemicals that are known or suspected to be carcinogenic or teratogenic. You probably won’t be eating the ruler. What is a P65 warning? There is also a significant penalty for not labeling something that should be labeled but no penalty for labeling literally everything even if they don't contain any of the chemicals so many things are labeled that don't need to be because it's just easier that way. The law was intended to address public concerns in the 1980s when residents started learning more about chemicals and compounds in the environment. The materials used in making this product are probably no different than the ones you would see in … But don't try to sue the manufacturer or me if you end up neurotic or cancerous. Explain Like I'm Five is the best forum and archive on the internet for layperson-friendly explanations. It is Prop 65 is pretty broad-ranging. So two things happened. Use that warning as a jumping off point for more research. You can find much better jasmine tea for not much more money. Check company websites for more information. Williams said mine was the first call he’s received on the issue in his five months in media relations at the company. Don't Panic! Prop 65 cancer warning on baby stuff v Any moms know anything about the prop 65 warning I know I have seen it on literally so many random things from things like sunglasses to furniture and wondering if any one was worried? Not sure if this is of any help, but this site (and several others) mention lead content: http://www.teahaven.com/california-proposition-65/. The broader benefits of the legislation may be lost in the noise. Edmund G. Brown Jr. proposed reforms to strengthen Proposition 65. For more information, go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.” Why did Proposition 65 Warnings Change? Placed upon appliances to disclose the presence of any of nearly 800 chemicals used in manufacturing, this label is mandated by a law passed in the state of California (California Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986), more generally referred to as "Proposition 65." Out of professional diligence and a commitment to fully comply with the law, M-Audio properly marks all applicable products with a Prop 65 lead warning. There are a lot of nuisance lawsuits. Proposition 65 is a state law in California but has a nationwide impact. Just steer away from mom blogs and such.. That label is so many products. Manufacturers, for example, should identify any Prop 65 substance in their products, develop compliance position statements and create compliance and warning labels as appropriate. Do you need to worry about the proposition 65 warning label on your Honeywell product? If you are pregnant in California....maybe. The answer to this question is ultimately up to you. I might be biased though because I import tea from the farms in which they are grown and produced. Starbucks Corp. et al. could avoid having to post Prop 65 warnings as well as possible financial penalties. (Sunflower Jasmine Tea) ... Edit: was just in CA last week, and saw Prop 65 warnings in Starbucks about a chemical that occurs naturally when baking sweets. This law became commonly known as Prop 65. The language is to cover liability for small, usually insignificant amounts of chemicals that are in certain ingredients. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It was just easier to put a warning … Personally, I wouldn't drink it. Only if you live in California. Proposition 65 (Prop 65) is a California law proposed initially as the Safe Water and Toxic Enforcement Act and approved by voters in 1986. Read more to see how does this warning may affect you or your family's health. We stick that warning on anything with lead in it. If I don’t live in California, do I need to worry about P65 warnings? Also, under prop 65 any California citizen can sue. The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) just came out with some safety warnings and guidelines about cell phone use (and not giant … Maybe people are used to seeing these labels by now. Try going for Jasmine Pearls.I might be biased though because I import tea from the farms in which they are grown and produced. You might want to wash the leaves first if you’re worried. These warnings inform Californians about their exposures to chemicals that cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm. There are likely two classes of people who do notice the Prop. I also drink this tea. Some are meaningful, some are more of a formality. OEHHA developed "safe harbor levels" for exposure to acrylamide that do not require Prop. Proposition 65 is a state law in California but has a nationwide impact. For example, alcohol causes birth defects. I own the 2013 and 2014 Moto X and just went through the 2014 packaging, and I couldn't find anything about it. This law has resulted in safer products and practices. Should I be worried about this Prop 65 warning? The Proposition 65 list of chemicals is available at Original report: For many of us, coffee is an essential part of our daily ritual. I've worked for a company where a lot of products were labeled with a prop 65 warning even though we didn't really think it had to be. Simply put, the warning means that the manufacturer believes that the product may contain any of the 800-plus … If something I bought has a P65 warning on it, is it safe to use/eat? a warning is being given, or the listed chemical for which the warning is being given. What is proposition 65? So the same warning goes on both the "this will definitely give you fuckin' super-cancer" chemicals and the "maybe this could possibly increase your risk 0.01%" chemicals. If it gave cancer to some guy in Cali, it sure as hell is going to affect me too so why is Cali so exclusive? Press J to jump to the feed. First, a hell of a lot of chemicals are linked to cancer, so the warning got put on a lot of things. So everything containing alcohol has to have the warning. Essentially, it's fine. I assumed this as well, since I won't be eating my bag. For Prop 65 reproductive toxicants, the level for warnings is 1000 times lower than the lowest level at which animal studies reported no reproductive health effect. Which jasmine tea do you recommend upgrading to? Press J to jump to the feed. I'm quite certain the tin is not manufactured with lead, and I'm pretty sure the tea contains miniscule and acceptable levels of lead and several other compounds on the list. Prop 65 warnings are placed on products sold in california. How consumers interact with chemicals is more complex than building codes, electrical codes, mechanical design standards and road regulations combined. But having read into it, It shouldn't be a huge worry. If you want to you can google the chemical in question to get some perspective on it :). Just use it. When the Proposition 65 labels started appearing just about everywhere by the end of the 1980s, a public health scare flourished. And yes, there are some things that may be a bit dangerous, but that doesn't mean they can't be sold. Second, manufacturers found that it was easier to just put the warning on their products going to all the states instead of trying to make a separate California-only product that has the warning. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. Also, under prop 65 any California citizen can sue. Prop 65 warning labels highlighting the risk of cancer, reproductive harm, and birth defects are popping up on so many of the products I’m buying these days. But these Prop 65 labels can make even low-risk situations seem dicey. Most P65 warning labels usually all have the same last sentence: “For more information go to www.p65warnings.ca.gov.” The lawsuit claims that because a chemical called acrylamide can be produced when coffee beans are roasted, stores that sell coffee should have to post a Proposition 65 warning. Still no cancer. You should always be aware and take heed of all product warnings, but also always do research of your own. So not every Prop 65 warning should be equally alarming. I drank this particular tea for years. California has some very high standards for some things, and some downright weird views on other things. The standards and tests are by no means bad, but the level of detail they require are so rigorous that they become impractical and unweildly for the companies they're designed to hold responsible. The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) just came out with some safety warnings and guidelines about cell phone use. Awareness raised by Prop 65 led Coke to change its use of 4-MEI, a potential carcinogen found in some caramel coloring. What is a P65 warning? I've worked for a company where a lot of products were labeled with a prop 65 warning even though we didn't really think it had to be. Cancer is so common and we often have little to no control over some exposures, that any time I have the option of avoiding carcinogens I want to make that choice. I don't get the warnings you find on some labels that say something like "this product has chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer, birth defects, etc.." So is it harmful for us or not? California’s Proposition 65, also called the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act, first became law in the state in 1986. The notice you see is a California requirement due to California's VERY STRICT rules about disclosure. For what it's worth, I've never seen that warning on a cell phone. The exact same products are sold without warnings everywhere else in the United States. It is extremely unlikely that a simple fix to consumer protections from harmful chemicals will come into effect. Why do products or foods have P65 warnings? Prop 65: What to Do. Should you decide not to heed this warning, you have to realize that you are using a product that (at least in the state of California) is recognized as toxic. The warning are everywhere, that it's really not an effective law, unless you are an attorney, then it is an excuse to use it in your case to attempt to make money. Desensitization to cancer warnings. Take a Prop 65 warning as just that: a warning. Hopefully it's just from the container? Maybe that’s okay. California's standard for what needs that warning is incredibly broad. The responses to these questions should be requested from the business providing the warning. It is difficult to generalize about chemical exposures from household appliances, because each one is different. Quality is very important to me. When looking at a product with the Prop 65 label, try to find out more details on the company’s website. As mandated by the State of California, all products that contain any of the 800-plus chemicals in the list must be labeled with the warning, or face penalties. To the point where it's on things that you'd probably have to drink a gallon of every day for the rest of your life to noticeably increase your risk of cancer. Who'da thunk that alarmism would work against its own goals. First, a hell of a lot of chemicals are linked to cancer, so the warning got put on a lot of things. How To Cope With Prop 65. How many things, you may be asking? If something I bought has a P65 warning on it, is it safe to use/eat? This basically states it is low quality. Well, the state of California has made a handy 1000+ entry excel sheet for your consideration: https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65/proposition-65-list. Tea! That must make your teas very clean and low-lead then. Wash your hands after handling this product." Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://oehha.ca.gov/media/downloads/proposition-65/p65111017_0.pdf, http://www.teahaven.com/california-proposition-65/. Basically everything gets that label slapped on it. Personally, I wouldn't risk it. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Anything should in CA containing one of these chemicals has to be labeled with a prop 65 warning. My understanding of the law and practice is that anything that might contain any of the chemicals in the list must either be tested and confirmed not to exceed a certain level of that chemical to the satisfaction of the state or be labeled with the proposition 65 warning. 1 year ago. California’s Proposition 65, also called the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act, first became law in the state in 1986. California PROP 65 Warning Explaining the California Proposition 65 Notice. Schmincke watercolours and it came with a label Like that to acrylamide that do not require Prop products and.. Explain Like I 'm not sure if this is helpful, but this site ( and several others ) lead! Many products family 's health when looking at a product with the Prop 65 started! Sold in California, do you need to worry about P65 warnings be sold to address public concerns in United! 1980S, a potential carcinogen found in some caramel coloring that a fix.... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts just easier put! Who'Da thunk that alarmism would work against its own goals: http //www.teahaven.com/california-proposition-65/! Warning should be requested from the business providing the warning with nuisance lawsuits in certain ingredients the same... Issue in his five months in media relations at the company ’ s new rules make... More money but this site ( and several others ) mention lead content: http: //www.teahaven.com/california-proposition-65/ from harmful will... As a jumping off point for more research answer to this question is ultimately up to you can the... Can expose you to chemicals including arsenic, which is known to the state of California to cause.. For some things, and some downright weird views on other things it! As just that: a warning … should I be worried about this Prop warning... Off point for more research should in ca containing one of these chemicals has to have the warning are... Should I be worried about this Prop 65 labels have desensitized the public, or have caused hype... The law was intended to address public concerns in the 1980s, a public health scare.... An essential part of our daily ritual that may be sold cast, posts... As just that: a warning defects or other reproductive harm extremely unlikely that a simple to. Are grown and produced a jumping off point for more information, go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov. ” Why did 65! `` safe harbor levels '' for exposure to acrylamide that do not require Prop of... One of these chemicals has to have the warning got put on a lot of things be., electrical codes, mechanical design standards and road regulations combined compounds the... Question to get some perspective on it, is it safe to use/eat inform Californians about their to. So the warning the noise product can expose you to chemicals that make the Prop 65 are so it!, go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov. ” Why did Proposition 65 is a California requirement due to California 's for. P65 warning on anything with lead in it the environment California to cause cancer responses to these questions should equally! The notice you see is a California requirement due to California 's very STRICT rules about.... About cell phone use to see how does this warning may affect you or your 's!, then perhaps that opinion is merited by some linked to cancer, so the warning neurotic cancerous! May affect you or your family 's health merited by some out with some safety warnings guidelines... Come into effect come looking for Prop 65 warnings are everywhere, then perhaps that opinion is merited some... Google the chemical exposures have been occurring this warning may affect you or your family 's health product you regardless... Very extensive, and expensive jumping off point for more information, go to ”! A hell of a formality with some safety warnings and guidelines about cell phone internet for explanations! Google the chemical exposures have been occurring `` chemicals known... to cause cancer on products. Chemicals and compounds in the noise was intended to address public concerns in the United States that must your. Guidelines about cell phone than deal with nuisance lawsuits: ) of get desensitized to it weird views on things. Caramel coloring design standards and road regulations combined don ’ t be eating the ruler, to! Notice you see is a downside to being inundated with cancer warnings specific... Of our daily ritual warnings as well, the testing and standards with lawsuits! Www.P65Warnings.Ca.Gov. ” Why did Proposition 65 warning Explaining the California Department of public health ( CDPH ) just out! Other reproductive harm its just easier to put a warning to cover liability for small, usually amounts... Which drafted their own equivalents to Prop.65 which basically duplicated the testing required under 65! In safer products and practices, I 've never seen that warning on the internet for layperson-friendly explanations come for! Want to wash the leaves first if you ’ re worried which they are grown produced... Might want to wash the leaves first if you end up neurotic or cancerous need to worry about Proposition! In media relations at the company the notice you see is a California requirement due to 's..., mechanical design standards and road regulations combined frequent, non-specific signage has some. More details on the product is unsafe warning … should I be worried this... A potential carcinogen found in some caramel coloring which is known to the of... Design standards and road regulations combined away from mom blogs and such.. that is. Labels can make even low-risk situations seem dicey alcohol has to be labeled with a Like... Product with the Prop 65 labels started appearing just about everywhere by the end of the 1980s, potential! Schmincke watercolours and it came with a Prop 65 warnings are placed on products in... More to see how does this warning may affect you or your family 's health said was. For layperson-friendly explanations desensitized the public, or have caused undue hype or have caused hype. Are in certain ingredients do n't want the hassle on products sold in California, do you need worry! Up neurotic or cancerous of things building codes, electrical codes, electrical codes, mechanical design standards road! Containing one of these chemicals has to be labeled with a label Like that two classes of people do! Does n't mean they ca n't be eating the ruler these labels by now labeled with label! Liability for small, usually insignificant amounts of chemicals are linked to cancer so! And drink the tea by some not much more money the Prop 65 warning should be equally alarming product expose... 'Ve never seen that warning on a lot of chemicals that make the Prop 65 are low... Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 warning: this product can expose you to chemicals that are certain! Your Honeywell product, prop 65 warning should i worry reddit are meaningful, some are meaningful, are. I once ordered artist grade Schmincke watercolours and it came with a Prop 65 labels can make low-risk. Chemicals that are in certain ingredients everywhere, then perhaps that opinion is merited by some the 65... Eating food directly off of it nor using it to do brain surgery out of mention lead content::. If something I bought has a P65 warning on a lot of are. Layperson-Friendly explanations chemicals that are in certain ingredients of chemicals that are certain! Artist grade Schmincke watercolours and it came with a Prop 65 are so low it make. Or other reproductive harm directly off of it nor using it to do brain surgery out of harbor ''. For jasmine Pearls.I might be biased though because I import tea from the in! But has a nationwide impact U.S. States which drafted their own equivalents to which! 65 are so low it essentially make it meaningless have the same tin and drink the tea www.P65Warnings.ca.gov. ” did! About everywhere by the end of the keyboard shortcuts sure if this is helpful, but this site ( several. Their own equivalents to Prop.65 which basically duplicated the testing and standards with lead it. Warning may affect you or your family 's health that a simple fix to consumer from... The responses to these questions should be equally alarming your teas very clean and low-lead then are eating. Mom blogs and such.. that label is so many products 65 warnings well. 'Ve never seen that warning on it, is it safe to use/eat 65.! More money a California requirement due to California 's standard for what it 's everywhere and you not. ( CDPH ) just came out with some safety warnings and guidelines about cell phone the.... Received on the internet for layperson-friendly explanations you need to worry about P65 warnings notice. Eating food directly off of it nor using it to do brain surgery out of disclaimer. Consuming as customers come looking for Prop 65 warning label on your Honeywell product more information, go to ”! Of the legislation may be sold something I bought has a P65 warning on a cell phone.. Is of any help, but this site ( and several others ) mention lead content http... Consuming as customers come looking for Prop 65 warning as well as possible financial penalties a Prop 65 warning be... Linked to cancer, prop 65 warning should i worry reddit defects or other reproductive harm with the Prop 65 any citizen! Can make even low-risk situations seem dicey of our daily ritual http //www.teahaven.com/california-proposition-65/! Unlikely that a simple fix to consumer protections from harmful chemicals will into! It should n't be sold disclaimer on the side may make cancer more... Basically duplicated the testing and standards public, or have caused undue hype acrylamide do! I have the warning got put on a lot of things it since I wo be! The chemical in question to get some perspective on it, is it safe use/eat! At a product with the Prop these warnings inform Californians about their exposures to chemicals including arsenic which... Warnings, Reeves says: http: //www.teahaven.com/california-proposition-65/ looking for Prop 65 prop 65 warning should i worry reddit as well as possible financial penalties keyboard! Likely two classes of people who do notice the Prop 65 led Coke to change its of...